Back to Blog Home Page
f you add AI to your tech stack—but no one actually uses it—did anything really change?
Over the past two years, TA teams have experienced an AI avalanche—new tools and “must-haves” flooding the market.
One key solution that has risen to the top of the AI recruitment software tech stack: AI interview tools,now commonly embedded within modern applicant tracking systems and hiring platforms.
More streamlined, consistent, quality interviews—what’s not to love?
But while AI interviewing can feel like a golden goose for TA teams and hiring managers alike, the reality is more nuanced. Sorting through what tools actually work, which solutions recruiters and candidates can trust, and how to implement AI within your applicant tracking software and recruitment management software can feel like doctorate-level research.
The good news: We’ve done the work.
This guide takes a clear, balanced look at AI interview tools—covering the features that matter most, the risks to consider, and the buyer questions TA teams should be asking before adding AI to their talent acquisition platform or recruitment system.
What AI Interview Tools Do
First and foremost, AI will never replace humans in the hiring process.
Think of this like an AI makeover. We want to use AI to enhance—not completely rebuild and replace—your people or processes within your recruitment applicant tracking workflows. The benefits should be clear, but the automation should never be front and center.
What does that look like in practice?
At a base level, AI interview tools:
- Automate interview summaries and feedback within your applicant tracking system software
- Shift interviewer focus from note-taking to candidate conversations
- Run more consistent, skills-aligned interviews for hiring managers
- Move qualified candidates through the process faster using intelligent candidate tracking
- Improve interview quality without adding administrative burden to your recruiting teams
Used well, AI creates a clear before-and-after—less friction for recruiters and a better experience for candidates.
However, not all solutions are created equal. And knowing which features individual solutions offer (or add-on) can be the difference between a classic success story and near-instant buyer’s remorse.
Key Features to Compare
Much like choosing your next binge-watch on Netflix, finding and selecting the right AI interview solution for your team can lead to a real case of analysis paralysis. When one solution offers ease of use while another has key integration features you can’t live without, how do you choose between the two? And what makes it a make-or-break?
Key AI Interview Features
When evaluating your potential AI Interview Companion solutions—often part of broader applicant tracking systems or candidate relationship management tools—it is critical to focus on the key must-haves that will drive adoption, usage, and ongoing enhancement for your TA pros.
Here’s what those key features should include:
Pre-interview prep: Set your team up for success before the first screening call with features that allow you to:
- Record intake meetings/notes
- Outline what each interviewer should accomplish during every interview
- Plan your interview process within your recruitment system for more effective outcomes
In-interview support: Look for tools that bring consistency without forced rigidity, providing:
- Recommended questions based on skills and hiring needs
- In-interview guidance
- Real-time feedback from hiring teams and candidates using hiring manager software
Interviewer coaching and development: Grow your team and grow your interviewers’ key skills and capabilities with:
- Post-interview coaching insights
- Feedback that helps interviewers improve over time
- Support for consistent interviewing standards across recruiting platforms and teams
Post-interview decisions backed by data: Move beyond resumes and intuition-based hiring choices, leveraging:
- Structured data for candidate comparison
- Reviewable interview moments or clips
- Detailed notetaking capabilities within applicant tracking software
Risks & Ethical Considerations
While AI might be the new bright and shiny investment no one can live without, it’s not without its potential risks—especially when embedded into talent acquisition software.
As quickly as AI entered hiring conversations, ethical considerations and implications followed. Never before has the word responsible made such a difference in technology.
In short, responsible AI keeps technology people-first, ensuring bias, black box models, and lack of safeguards don’t derail your team and open your organization up to major ethical pitfalls.
Bias, Transparency, and Compliance
To really put the responsible in responsible AI, teams need to be proactively assessing the risks and ethical implications of any AI tool they may consider integrating into their systems. Productivity is always top of mind, but if it comes at the expense of transparency and explainability, the cost is too great.
When evaluating your AI interview tools consider how the vendor approaches:
- Bias monitoring: Does the vendor provide real-time, continuous bias checks across all data, or is it just point-in-time checks?
- Transparency and explainability: Do you have clear visibility into how AI generates recommendations, including what data it uses and how those outputs are evaluated?
- Audit-readiness: Does the solution include built-in auditability for regulators, legal teams, and leadership?
- Safeguards and controls: What kinds of guardrails are in place? Are there continuous guardrails that ensure responsible, explainable AI use?
- Transparent usage: Are candidates notified that AI tools are used throughout the process? How are they notified?
Integration Best Practices
Picture this: you find the most perfect AI interview tool. It meets your needs and exceeds your expectations and, of course, is fully responsible. But it doesn’t integrate with your existing TA tech stack—your applicant tracking system, recruiting tools, and recruitment software—so no one uses it.
The first step to usability? Integrations with systems your team is already familiar with.
At a base level, your AI interview tool should integrate with:
- Your ATS and other recruitment automation software
- Your Human Resources Information System (HRIS)
- Your video interview tools
- Your calendaring/scheduling system
But beyond these core points of integration, strong solutions will also prioritize:
- Single sign-on (SSO) to reduce login friction
- Role-based permissions to protect sensitive data
- API access
Buyer Checklist & Evaluation Questions
So, now you know your must-have and nice-to-have features, have a clear picture of what integrations will make or break usability, and understand how ethics and compliance work into the bigger picture.
But knowing what to look for is only half the equation. The next step is asking the right questions to surface how a solution actually works in practice.
To help get you started, here are a few questions to guide your vendor conversations:
- How does this solution support structured, consistent interview processes?
- How transparent and explainable are the AI-generated insights?
- What interview data—video, notes, insights—does the tool capture to support data-driven hiring decisions?
- What safeguards exist to monitor bias, accuracy, and performance continuously?
- How does the solution integrate into the existing applicant tracking system, recruiting tools, and recruitment software?
Going a step further, a buyer’s checklist can help you compare and contrast tools and vendors. So, you never have to doubt your decision or risk buyer’s remorse:
Tool assessment
- Plans the interview process for more effective outcomes: intake forms, pre-interview prep, interview goals and process planning
- Guides the interviewer in real-time: serve recommended questions based on skills needed for the role
- Improves quality of hire with actionable interview data: video clips, notes, real-time insights
- Enables a standardized interview process
- Automates interview summaries & feedback collection
- Automates interviewer coaching: coachable moments and summaries
- Enables better decision making
Integrations assessment
- Integrates with existing tech stack: ATS, video interview tools (Zoom, Teams, etc.), calendaring/scheduling systems
- SSO functionality
- Role- and permission-based access
Ethical assessment
- Clear explanation of AI decision-making processes
- No “black box” algorithms
- Ability to provide reasoning for recommendations
- Built-in bias detection and mitigation tools
- Clear data-handling policies
- Always-on governance and monitoring for fairness
Vendor assessment
- AI ethics and governance policies are embedded in the development process
- Transparency about AI development, training data sources, and testing processes
- Ongoing support and trainings
- References from organizations with similar use cases
The right AI interview tool will do more than add intelligence into your recruitment management software/tech stack—it will amplify your team’s ability to find the right fit, right talent, and right hire for your most critical roles. All while keeping your hiring process deeply human.
Ready to see how Lever, a trusted Employ ATS, approaches AI interviewing with care and clarity? Learn how Lever’s AI Interview Companion supports structured, human-centered interviews within your talent acquisition platform. Download our product guide for all the details and data or schedule a demo to see it in action.
